Press Release · Lumina Foundation
Academic progress requirements put financial aid at risk for 1.8 million students, new national study finds
Distributed by NetFrame · Originally issued via PR Newswire

Report highlights how colleges can make common-sense changes to help students stay on track to graduate.
INDIANAPOLIS, Nov. 18, 2026 — Millions of students depend on federal financial aid to afford college, but until now, there has been little national evidence on how many struggle to meet satisfactory academic progress (SAP) requirements and lose access to that aid. A new national evaluation from Lumina F https://www.luminafoundation.org/oundation and Mathematica provides the first comprehensive national look at how SAP requirements are implemented, how many students lose financial aid eligibility, and what colleges can do to better support students.
The report found that 13 percent of undergraduates, or more than 1.8 million students, failed SAP requirements in spring 2025. More than half of those students (54 percent, or approximately 970,000 students) lost eligibility for federal financial aid for the following term.
To maintain federal financial aid eligibility, students must maintain a minimum grade-point average—typically at least a C average—and complete enough courses to graduate within a certain timeframe. The findings show that colleges can do more to help students understand these requirements, stay on track academically, and maintain their financial aid eligibility.
The consequences were especially pronounced at two-year institutions, where 22 percent of students failed SAP, compared with 8 percent at public four-year institutions and 5 percent at private four-year institutions. Financial aid administrators also most often identified first-generation, low-income, and first-year students as groups that struggle to meet SAP requirements, underscoring the need for strong advising and other support systems for student success.
"For the first time, we have a national picture of how many students are losing financial aid eligibility because they aren't meeting satisfactory academic progress requirements," said Ira Nichols-Barrer, principal researcher at Mathematica. "The scale is much larger than previously understood, but colleges have opportunities to help more students maintain their aid and stay enrolled through clearer communication, earlier intervention, and greater awareness of the appeals process."
Appeals can preserve aid eligibility, but many students never apply
Researchers found that only about one-quarter of students who failed SAP submitted an appeal, even though approximately 75 percent of appeals were approved. All participating institutions offered an appeals process, pointing to an opportunity for colleges to better inform students about their options and help them navigate the process.
Colleges have room to strengthen SAP policies and student support
Federal rules set baseline requirements while giving institutions discretion in how they implement SAP. Yet most institutions are not taking advantage of existing flexibility that could help students stay on track, such as gradually increasing GPA and course-completion requirements during students' early years while still meeting federal standards.
Colleges can also provide earlier warnings, simplify the appeals process, and better coordinate academic advising with financial aid offices so students receive consistent guidance.
"Students who fall behind academically need clear information and support to get back on track. Losing financial aid can make that much harder," said Janai Raphael, strategy officer at Lumina. "Colleges have options within the existing rules to help more students keep their aid. That starts with reaching students earlier, explaining their options, and making sure they know how to appeal."
The findings also have implications for Lumina's Goal 2040, which aims for 75 percent of the U.S. labor force to hold a college degree or other credential of value by 2040. Helping more students maintain financial aid eligibility and complete their education is an important part of reaching that goal.
Read the full report: Satisfactory Academic Progress Policies and Student Aid Eligibility: A National Evaluation.
Media contact(s):
Kirsten Miller, Mathematica
[email protected]
Tracy Chen, Lumina Foundation
[email protected]
SOURCE Lumina Foundation
About Mathematica: Mathematica is an employee-owned company advancing public well-being through rigorous evidence, practical expertise, and a commitment to impact. We bring together policy experts, data scientists, methodologists, and technologists to design, test, and scale solutions that improve outcomes and drive meaningful change. We work with leaders across the public, private, and philanthropic sectors to help them meet their goals and turn data and evidence into action. Learn more at Mathematica.
About Lumina: Lumina Foundation is an independent, private foundation in Indianapolis committed to making opportunities for learning beyond high school available to all. We envision higher learning that is easy to navigate, delivers fair results, and meets the nation's talent needs through a broad range of credentials. We work toward a system that prepares people for informed citizenship and success in a global economy.